From First To Last - We Were Bleeding Anyway EP
From First To Last’s return has never felt like a straightforward nostalgia play. The band’s history is too messy, too restless, and too deeply intertwined with the evolution of post-hardcore, screamo, and emo to simply recreate the past. On We Were Bleeding Anyway, their new six-track EP, the Florida veterans instead revisit the instincts that made them compelling in the first place while allowing two decades of experience, loss, and musical evolution to reshape them.
To be released on October 2, 2026, through Fearless Records, We Were Bleeding Anyway is a record about remembering what made From First To Last special without becoming imprisoned by it.
The band’s DNA is impossible to miss. From the opening moments, We Were Bleeding Anyway understands the particular alchemy that defined early From First To Last: guitars that can be both massive and melodic, choruses built for collective screaming, sudden shifts in dynamics, and breakdowns that feel less like compositional devices than physical events. But the EP rarely sounds like a band desperately trying to prove that it can still do what it did in 2004.
Instead, it sounds like musicians who finally understand exactly why those old songs worked. That distinction becomes especially important with Lil Lotus now behind the microphone. Anyone stepping into the vocalist position of From First To Last would be confronted with the enormous shadow of Sonny Moore, whose work on Dear Diary, My Teen Angst Has a Bodycount helped make the band one of the defining acts of its generation. Lotus wisely avoids attempting an impression. His voice has its own identity, moving from a naturally melodic delivery into visceral screams when the songs demand them.
On We Were Bleeding Anyway, that contrast becomes one of the band's greatest strengths. The EP opens with “They Said Your Ghost Was A Promise,” and it is difficult to imagine a more direct statement of intent. The song takes virtually every ingredient associated with From First To Last and turns the volume up: huge guitars, a gigantic chorus, emotionally charged vocals, and a breakdown designed to rearrange internal organs. It is unabashedly an anthem, the kind of song that seems to anticipate a crowd screaming every word back at the band.
The repeated “Do you want to” toward the song's conclusion is almost ridiculously effective. It is simple, obvious, and completely irresistible—the sort of moment that explains why this band has remained important to people long after the scene that originally embraced them moved on.
More importantly, the song's emotional weight isn't merely manufactured for the sake of an enormous chorus. “They Said Your Ghost Was A Promise” deals with the loss of a loved one, giving its catharsis something substantial underneath the spectacle. The guitars may be built to shake a venue, but the song's center is grief.
That balance between emotional vulnerability and sheer heaviness runs throughout the entire EP. “Your Name In Red Ink” and “Everything Ends In Silence” continue exploring the darker emotional territory established by the opener, while retaining the dramatic songwriting that has always separated From First To Last from straightforward metalcore. There is a deliberate push and pull between restraint and release. A quieter or more melodic passage isn't simply an interlude before the next breakdown; it gives the heavier sections somewhere to land.
That sense of dynamics is one of the most important connections between the new material and the band's early work. From First To Last's best songs have always understood that heaviness means more when there is something to contrast it against. Aesthetic was chaotic and youthful. Dear Diary sharpened that chaos into something immediate and melodic. Heroine expanded the band's ambitions without eliminating the volatility underneath. We Were Bleeding Anyway feels like another stage in that progression—not a return to the beginning, but an acknowledgment of what the beginning established.
“Picking Clothes To Die In” is perhaps the title that best captures the EP's morbid emotional atmosphere. There is a maturity to the new band's darkness that comes from having actually lived through the years between records. These aren't songs written by teenagers trying to understand what pain might feel like. They come from people who have experienced loss, fractured relationships, departures, reunions, and the complicated business of rebuilding a life. That perspective gives the EP a different kind of urgency compared to their previous releases.
“Hate Me All You Want I Still Got Your...” carries some of the bitterness implied by its title, while the acoustic-enforced “Pale Blue” closes the record by emphasizing the EP's more reflective side. Across six tracks, From First To Last maintain the band's familiar emotional extremes without reducing those extremes to nostalgia, and that is ultimately what makes We Were Bleeding Anyway work.
There are plenty of reunion records that sound like an old band putting on its old uniform. From First To Last instead sounds like a band reopening an old box of tools and discovering that the tools still work—but that they've learned new ways to use them. Matt Good's decades of songwriting and production experience are audible in the confidence of the arrangements. Travis Richter brings the history and physicality of the band's original sound, while his work with If I Die First provides an obvious bridge between From First To Last's formative influence and the musical world that followed it.
Lotus is the crucial piece of that equation, however. His history as a fan gives him an instinctive understanding of the band's emotional language, but his own career means he doesn't have to impersonate the people who came before him. He sounds like someone who grew up with From First To Last, absorbed their lessons, and then found his own voice. That makes his presence feel less like a replacement and more like an unlikely continuation of the band's story.
There is also something satisfying about the fact that the band's current lineup emerged organically rather than from a grand plan. One demo became several songs. Several songs became live performances. Live performances became a new version of the band. That organic progression seems appropriate for a group whose earliest music was built around the idea that songs didn't have to obey a predetermined set of rules.
We Were Bleeding Anyway doesn't either. It can be melodic without becoming soft, heavy without becoming predictable, and polished without losing its rough edges. Most importantly, it still understands the value of a song that feels like it might explode.
The title is appropriately bleak, but there is something hopeful buried inside the EP. From First To Last have survived the breakup cycles, lineup changes, side projects, long absences, and the inevitable distance that grows between a band's formative years and its future. They aren't pretending that time hasn't passed. They're using it as a benefit to themselves.
We Were Bleeding Anyway is therefore less a comeback than a continuation—a six-song reminder that the band's defining quality was never a particular singer, scene, or era. It was the refusal to choose between contradiction and chaos, melody and aggression, vulnerability and violence. More than twenty years later, that uncertainty still suits them.
Find out more about From First to Last:
Comments